2025 Topps Now Matthew Schaefer #5 Youngest Dman Ever to Record Point in NHL Debut New York Islanders Rookie RC Hockey Card

$54.99

Amazon.com

500 LEVEL Matthew Schaefer New York Elite Shirt (Royal Blue, Medium)

$31.99

Amazon.com

2025-26 Upper Deck #P-32 Matthew Schaefer UD Portraits Rookie RC Hockey Card

$36.50

Amazon.com

Matthew Schaefer 2025 U.D. Star Rookies #5 Special Collection Rookie Card PGI 10

$39.99

Amazon.com

2025-26 Matthew Schaefer Hockey Rookie Trading 2 Card Lot Star Rookies #5 and NhCD2 Islanders Young Superstar Player! You Will Receive Both Cards Shown

$59.49

Amazon.com

500 LEVEL Matthew Schaefer New York Name Number Shirt (Royal Blue, Large)

$31.99

Amazon.com

Matthew Schaefer Overtime Goal T Shirt S Navy

$24.99

Amazon.com

Matthew Schaefer - Schaef Daddy - New York Hockey Comfort Colors Adult Heavyweight T-Shirt

$27.99

Amazon.com

500 LEVEL Matthew Schaefer New York Pose Men's Premium T-Shirt (Tri Black, Small)

$37.99

Amazon.com

New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer Blue Men's N&N Jersey T-Shirt- Large

$44.99

Amazon.com